2123 Avenue U

If you live in the Sheepshead Bay area, you might have seen the activity. While things for the cafe and community center are still in the rough, we are seeing exciting progress! See the plans by clicking below.

See the Renderings
interior view

Craft Coffee | Artisan Fare | Books

Join our email list and you’ll be one of the first to know what is happening. We’re still working on our menu, but when it’s ready, we will send you a coupon for a Free cup of coffee or some other special selection from our menu.

Sign up Now

Coming in Late 2020 or early 2021

A Coffee Shop and Community Space 

Follow us on Instagram For Updates

This error message is only visible to WordPress admins
There has been a problem with your Instagram Feed.

Meet the Shepherd’s Cup Team


Sam Stoltzfus

shed website design in pa

Chris Stoltzfus


AJ Rotelle

brentrhoda 6719

Brent Stoltfus

e impact 5759

Kenneth Kauffman


Austin Musser


Mark Schlabach


Welcome to Shepherd’s Cup, an up and coming cafe serving artisan coffee, Turkish and PA Dutch pastries, paninis, homemade soups, salad and featuring a self serve yogurt bar in a warm atmosphere in Sheepshead Bay New York. Here you can find out what to expect, stay tuned on the news and watch the progress.

Progress Gallery

We are making progress in the renovation of Shepherd’s Cup. Attached are a few photos of the journey.

installing windows
removing safe
shepherds cup
shepherdscup brooklyn ny
shepherds cup interior work