2123 Avenue U

If you live in the Sheepshead Bay area, you might have seen the activity. While things for the cafe and community center are still in the rough, we are seeing exciting progress! See the plans by clicking below.

See the Renderings
interior view

Craft Coffee | Artisan Fare | Books

Join our email list and you’ll be one of the first to know what is happening. We’re still working on our menu, but when it’s ready, we will send you a coupon for a Free cup of coffee or some other special selection from our menu.

Sign up Now

Coming in Late 2020 or early 2021

A Coffee Shop and Community SpaceΒ 

Follow us on Instagram For Updates

Autumn Drink Feature:

What if apple cider and steamed milk found each other? Add some caramel and cinnamon and it's the Caramel Apple Cider Latte currently trending at our cafe. Give it a try!

#nyccafe #nyccoffeeshop #brooklyncafe
#brooklyncoffeeshop #turkishnyc
#specialtycoffeeandtea
#newcafeinbrooklyn #nowopeninbrooklyn
#beautifulcafe #breakfastinbrooklyn
#lunchinbrooklyn #dinnerinbrooklyn #snackinbrooklyn
#hotdrinkinbrooklyn
#autumnspecialsinbrooklyn
#caramelappleciderlatte
...

Autumn Drink Feature:

Is it sweater weather yet?! This morning is quite convincing. Either way, we're pretty sure you'll enjoy a mug of steaming apple cider. Or enjoy it chilled if that's more your thing.

We're happy to be serving @kauffmanorchards very own fresh pressed apple cider. 🍎

#nyccafe #nyccoffeeshop #brooklyncafe
#brooklyncoffeeshop #turkishnyc
#specialtycoffeeandtea
#newcafeinbrooklyn #nowopeninbrooklyn
#beautifulcafe #breakfastinbrooklyn
#lunchinbrooklyn #dinnerinbrooklyn #snackinbrooklyn
#hotdrinkinbrooklyn
#autumnspecialsinbrooklyn
#applecider
...

Autumn Drink Feature:

Greet the first day of fall with a Maple Brown Sugar Latte! 🍁Layered within this creamy cup are the flavors of fall...sweet maple, brown sugar and a little cinnamon spice. Mmm...

#nyccafe #nyccoffeeshop #brooklyncafe
#brooklyncoffeeshop #turkishnyc
#specialtycoffeeandtea
#newcafeinbrooklyn #nowopeninbrooklyn
#beautifulcafe #breakfastinbrooklyn
#lunchinbrooklyn #dinnerinbrooklyn #snackinbrooklyn #latteinbrooklyn
#autumnspecialsinbrooklyn
#maplebrownsugarlatte
...

Here's to curling your hands around a hot latte, finding a cozy corner to relax, and sipping every bit as slowly as you'd like. Happy weekend everyone! β˜•

#nyccafe #nyccoffeeshop #brooklyncafe
#brooklyncoffeeshop #turkishnyc
#specialtycoffeeandtea
#newcafeinbrooklyn #nowopeninbrooklyn
#beautifulcafe #breakfastinbrooklyn
#lunchinbrooklyn #dinnerinbrooklyn #snackinbrooklyn #weekendinbrooklyn
...

Autumn Special Introduction:

Calling the name of everyone who has a sweet tooth, this is the Pumpkin Maple Smashed Croissant. 🍁 Filled with pumpkin butter from @kauffmanorchards in Lancaster County, PA, and grilled in the panini press, it's then smothered in brown sugar, cinnamon, walnuts and maple syrup. Grab your fork! 🍴

#nyccafe #nyccoffeeshop #brooklyncafe
#brooklyncoffeeshop #turkishnyc
#specialtycoffeeandtea
#newcafeinbrooklyn #nowopeninbrooklyn
#beautifulcafe #breakfastinbrooklyn
#lunchinbrooklyn #dinnerinbrooklyn #snackinbrooklyn
#autumnspecialsinbrooklyn
#pumpkinmaplesmashedcroissant
...

Autumn Special Introduction:

Nothing says fall like squash. Our cook has prepared a creamy butternut squash soup that will keep you warm all season long as the days turn colder. Enjoy this savory soup alongside garlic buttered bread. πŸ₯–

#nyccafe #nyccoffeeshop #brooklyncafe
#brooklyncoffeeshop #turkishnyc
#specialtycoffeeandtea
#newcafeinbrooklyn #nowopeninbrooklyn
#beautifulcafe
#lunchinbrooklyn #dinnerinbrooklyn
#autumnspecialsinbrooklyn
#butternutsquashsoup
...

Autumn Special Introduction:

How about some fresh greens paired with crisp tart apples? This is the Harvest Apple Salad Bowl! 🍏

Tossed with arugula, spring mix and baby spinach, this salad bowl mixes in shaved apple, walnuts, dried cranberries, feta cheese, and a sweet apple vinaigrette.

#nyccafe #nyccoffeeshop #brooklyncafe
#brooklyncoffeeshop #turkishnyc
#specialtycoffeeandtea
#newcafeinbrooklyn #nowopeninbrooklyn
#beautifulcafe
#lunchinbrooklyn #dinnerinbrooklyn
#autumnspecialsinbrooklyn
#harvestapplesaladbowl
...

Autumn Special Introduction:

Here's the Autumn Turkey Sandwich! πŸ₯ͺ It's a bit of a dagwood with many layers of both sweet and savory seasonal flavors.

Beginning with whole wheat sourdough, enjoy layers of hummus, red onion, roasted sweet potato, avocado, apple, deli turkey and spinach. Served with a side of hummus and cucumber.

#nyccafe #nyccoffeeshop #brooklyncafe
#brooklyncoffeeshop #turkishnyc
#specialtycoffeeandtea
#newcafeinbrooklyn #nowopeninbrooklyn
#beautifulcafe
#lunchinbrooklyn #dinnerinbrooklyn
#autumnspecialsinbrooklyn
#autumnturkeysandwich
...

Meet the Shepherd’s Cup Team

sam

Sam Stoltzfus

shed website design in pa

Chris Stoltzfus

aj

AJ Rotelle

brentrhoda 6719

Brent Stoltfus

e impact 5759

Kenneth Kauffman

austin

Austin Musser

mark

Mark Schlabach

#TasteAndSee

Welcome to Shepherd’s Cup, an up and coming cafe serving artisan coffee, Turkish and PA Dutch pastries, paninis, homemade soups, salad and featuring a self serve yogurt bar in a warm atmosphere in Sheepshead Bay New York. Here you can find out what to expect, stay tuned on the news and watch the progress.

Progress Gallery

We are making progress in the renovation of Shepherd’s Cup. Attached are a few photos of the journey.

installing windows
removing safe
shepherds cup
shepherdscup brooklyn ny
shepherds cup interior work